Archive for the ‘GBR’ Category
In a review of the world’s media in the last fortnight, the range of side effects to the flu vaccine is increasing. We have headlines blaring “the cure may be worse than the disease” and notifications of at least a third of British doctors refusing to administer a vaccine.
However, not all of these “side effects” are clinical – some are educational whilst others are based in incorrect perceptions and assumptions. This article is something of a catch-all incorporating published stories related to side effects, mis-diagnoses and assumptions.
We are repeatedly reading tales of mis-diagnoses of swine flu in the first place. Recently a 17-year-old English girl was diagnosed with swine flu, no fewer than 4 times, when in fact she had meningitis as the symptoms appeared similar to swine flu. She is making slow recovery, but the delays in correct diagnosis caused loss of valuable time.
Indeed, we do need to closely look at what is in fact being diagnosed. It’s not as simple as assuming a bug may be swine flu, what with new variants – including where swine flu strain is moving to birds - will be causing the medical community enormous challenges.
Looking to anti-virals – the most common ones being Tamiflu and Relenza (manufactured by Roche Holdings AG and Glaxo SmithKline PLC, respectively) – there has been significant and confusing commentary in recent weeks. Whilst Tamiflu (in existence since 1999) reduces the “miserable symptoms” of swine flu and can shorten the period of illness, it shouldn’t be viewed as a panacea as perhaps had been suggested by the UK government’s mass distribution of Tamiflu mid-summer (with over 100,000 packages given to children, alone). Further study is showing its effectiveness limited to about an 8% benefit in healthy adults.
According to the British Medical Journal, the “limited data” available shows that children under 12 are being reported as suffering vomiting and nightmares as a result of taking Tamiflu. Dr Matthew Thompson, a GP and researcher at Oxford University, cites drinks to cool temperatures and rest as the most effective treatment for flu in children. Even some adults are found to have experienced “little impact” on the length of their illness, or “limited benefit”.
The situation is even less clear for vaccines. With at least two manufacturers of a swine flu vaccine (Baxter in the USA and Sinovac Biotech in China being a couple that come to mind), governments around the world have had the confidence to books orders numbering in the tens of millions of doses. However, its suitability for human purpose is still in doubt as there has been relatively low amounts of testing.
According to Forbes.com, Sinovac has been testing for less than a month, on just over 1,600 people showing that the vaccine has “good immunogenicity” and thus fit for use. Additional research monies are being released worldwide, with one example being Canada whose government has just released $2.7 million (CDN) on top of the $10.8 million (CDN) already identified for fighting swine flu (CBC). But no amount of money can help the critical factor of time to allow completeness of clinical studies – GSK, for example will not be finishing its testing of the swine flu shot until mid-2010 — long after both the predicted “second wave” and “third wave” of swine flu will have hit.
The biggest concern around the actual threat of the vaccine is because it (Panderix) contains thimerosal, a mercury-laden preservative which has actually been removed from most mainstream vaccines because of the clear links to neurological effects. The mercury-free version is called Celvapan – do note however that there may be trace amounts of mercury as manufacturers are even in that case allowed to call the product “mercury free”.
Children are at greatest risk from these issues because they do not have a well developed immune system, their bodies are still growing, and pregnant mothers in many countries will be given the vaccine as a priority if they suspect swine flu. In Texas, where 14 children have already died from swine flu, there is a plan to immunise children in the schools themselves.
But what are the actual risks? Over and above the hit to the neuro system from the mercury, there are two significant risks being revealed:
- risk of “Guillain-Barr Syndrome (GBS) in which paralysis of the breathing muscles cause death by suffocation”. We have proven examples of this following the 1976 mass vaccination programme in the US where over 500 cases (of whom 25 people died, compared to 1 death as a result of swine flu) of GBS were detected. At its worst, GBS can prove fatal.
- German lung specialist, Dr Wolfgang Wodarg is deeply concerned about the possible risk of cancer in humans as the vaccine “consists of cancerous cells from animals”.
These don’t appear to be isolated concerns. According to the Associated Press, about half of health workers in Hong Kong would reject having the swine flu vaccine and in the UK at least a third of GPs are refusing to administer it.
Whilst many counter with the argument that the number of people the vaccine saves is greater than the number it harms, perhaps the real comparison needs to be (like in the 1976 example) how many will the vaccine kill as compared to swine flu? Clearly, this would be the most tragic of all flu vaccine side effects.
Further 360 reading:
- Swine flu’s rapid spreading in major cities of India – Swine Flu is rapidly spreading in all the parts of India. Currently 783 peoples are affected by this flu in India and 4 dead due to this serious flu. Government have taken many steps to stop this communicable disease. …
- Flu Shot Ingredients | Cure Swine Flu Information – In addition, some people are allergic to mercury and thimerosal and can experience serious allergic reaction as flu vaccine side effects. Some states have banned mercury from flu shot ingredients intended for use in children and …
- H1N1 Swine Flu Vaccine Side Effects Could Cause Death « Web of … – H1N1 Swine Flu Vaccine Side Effects Could Cause Death. 08/17/2009 · Leave a Comment. Related: Vaccine overview: Basic information on M59 Squalene Vaccine Adjuvant. Categories: Pandemic · Vaccines Tagged: M59. 0 responses so far ↓ …
- H1N1 Swine Flu Vaccine Side Effects Could Cause Death « Revealed Truth – H1N1 Swine Flu Vaccine Side Effects Could Cause Death. 2009 August 11. tags: Baxter, Cause, contaminated, Death, Donald, h1n1, Medicine, Rumsfeld, Swine Flu, University, Vaccine. by Revealed Truth …
- Media Hiding Swine Flu Vaccine Side Effects « – Media Hiding Swine Flu Vaccine Side Effects. August 19, 2009 · Leave a Comment. SWINE FLU VACCINES MAY HAVE MAJOR MEDICAL THREAT. Swine flu or the H1N1 virus has claimed the lives of 1500 people across the world. …
- Swine Flu Vaccine Side Effects | Cure Swine Flu Information – Now you’ve probably already heard about potential side effects of the swine flu vaccine. Certainly if you’ve read much of this site we specifically recommended.